Layman’s Summary by Helen & Barry Setterfield In 1940, after examining ‘outer space,’ scientists came to the conclusion that the universe had started from a pinpoint and quickly expanded. Critics mocked this, calling it the “Big Bang.” The name stuck, although it actually referred to a giant expansion. To this day, many preachers and others still mock that concept, saying God created our universe just as it is. What’s interesting is that God disagrees. Not once, not twice, but twelve times in the Bible, God says HE stretched out the heavens. Whereas standard science cannot explain where the energy for this expansion came from, the Bible says God did it. So what happened to all that energy? Einstein’s famous equation E=mc2 indicates that energy can become mass and mass can become energy. So are all the galaxies and planets and stars the result of all that energy? They are certainly the result of some of it, but by no means all. In 1901, a scientist, Max Planck, was working with a radiation problem. He found if he inserted an unknown variable, ‘h,’ into the equations, everything worked out quite well. That excited a lot of scientists, but Max was not happy with it being an unknown. What was ‘h?’ It took him ten years, but in 1911, he came out with another paper, in which he defined ‘h’ as the measure of energy in what is referred to as the ‘vacuum of space’ [1]. In part because of excitement over his first paper, and in part because the concept of some sort of energy being all though space was a strange one, science stayed with the first paper, and the final result was the math we know today as quantum mechanics or QED physics. Then, in 1925, Robert Mulliken was looking at a boron monoxide molecule. He saw that electrons were being shifted out of their orbits by some force [2]. He immediately connected that force, that energy, with Planck’s ‘h’ in the 1911 paper. A year previously, however, a young man named de Broglie had written his doctorate [3]. The work in that doctorate ended up inspiring three other papers which were the bases of quantum physics. In quantum physics, ‘h’ simply remains an unknown with no physical meaning. So Mulliken’s work did not attract a lot of attention. But in 1947, working with hydrogen, Lamb and Rutherford found the same thing Mulliken had found. Something was disturbing the electrons in their orbits [4]. A man named Casimir wanted to settle the arguments that were developing and theorized that if two metal plates were brought close enough together, the outside energy should push them together [5]. It was not for about ten years that we had the ability to do this experiment, which is now known as the Casimir Effect [6]. The Casimir experiment was done by putting the two metal plates in a container in which every atom and molecule in the surrounding air had been removed. There was still heat. Heat is energy. So the whole thing was cooled to as close to absolute zero as possible. No molecules, no atoms, no heat – nothing. But the two plates clapped together when they were brought close. What was doing that? Enter the Zero Point Energy. Whatever this was, was present at absolute zero, and so it was named the Zero Point Energy, usually abbreviated to ZPE. Planck’s ‘h’ was, and is, the measure of the strength of the Zero Point Energy.
Most of us are familiar with the times we stretched a rubber band or inflated a balloon. When we do that, we are putting some of our own energy into the fabric of the balloon or rubber band. But until we let go, that energy is not doing anything. That is potential energy. The moment you release the balloon or rubber band, however, the potential energy converts to kinetic, or active, energy, and the thing goes flying. However, the conversion does not happen instantaneously. The balloon flips and whirls around the room as the reducing fabric forces air out. Then it slows down and, at some point the conversion is complete and the balloon falls to the ground. The rubber band flies away very quickly at first and then it, too, slows down and falls to the ground. If God stretched out the heavens – the universe – He was putting some of His energy into it. That was potential energy which started to convert to kinetic energy at an extremely rapid pace at the beginning and then, much later, slowed down and finished the conversion. As it turned out, without going into more history and even more mathematics, Planck’s ‘h’ is a measure of the strength of the ZPE. Has the ZPE strength changed through time? There is a very strong indication that it has, and very rapidly at first. The clue is in something called the red shift. When electrons emit their bits of light – their photons – the position of the electron determines the color of light it emits. Each of the electrons in any atom emits one particular color. Lots of electrons getting snapped about means various colors are emitted. For this reason, each element has its own color code – something like the bar code on what you buy. In our part of space, we know exactly where each line in the bar is for each element:
Here on earth, as well as in our galaxy and even in nearby galaxies, these lines are exactly where they are supposed to be on the color spectrum. But as we look farther out, the entire “bar code” for each element shifts to the red side of the spectrum. The farther out we go, the more it shifts:
What would be causing this? Well, if the universe were still expanding, then the redshift might be something called a Doppler Effect. You hear this every time a siren passes you. The sound starts high coming toward you and then drops suddenly as it passes you. Perhaps the same thing was happening with light, like this:
The accepted idea regarding the red shift is that as light moves to the left on this diagram, or toward us, it is more compressed. The redshift to the right, compared to where we are on the left, is due to motion. There are two major problems with this explanation. The first is readily seen from the above diagram. With sound, the wavelengths, or the distance between wave peaks, is consistent when the siren is coming toward you and also consistent, but at a lower pitch, as it passes you and moves away. If you look at the light waves, that is not what you see. From violet to red, there is a continuous shift in wavelengths, and as you go into infrared, past what we can see, the wavelengths grow quite long. So no matter where you point to on that color spectrum, there is no ‘breaking point’ as there is with sound – the variation continues smoothly. The second problem is worse. It was found that, as we look farther and farther back, the measurements going from one part of the redshift to another are not smooth, but go in jumps [7]. When this was first discovered, the idea of it was mocked, and a number of astronomers set out to take measurements for themselves to prove the idea of jumps was wrong. Instead, they confirmed, over and over again, that the redshift measurements went from one number to another without anything in between – as though a car on the freeway could jump from 50 to 55 miles per hour with nothing in between [8]. So either the universe is expanding in jumps, or the redshift is not the result of ongoing expansion of the universe. (In fact, if it were the result of expansion, then the outer parts of our universe would be expanding at close to the speed of light because the redshift is so high out there. And if THAT were true, we should see massive disruption of those far away galaxies, but we don’t. They are holding together nicely.) There is an option: the ZPE. If it started out very low, just as the potential to kinetic change was starting, then the energy being supplied to the new atoms was also low, which means the light emitted by the electrons would be much redder than our light today. OK, if this is to be considered, what about the jumps in measurements that we see? If you push against a heavy table, it will resist moving until you push harder and then it will jerk forward. Matter behaves this way – it resists change until it can’t resist anymore and then it must accommodate that change. Atoms are the same. So they resisted the building ZPE until they couldn’t resist it any longer and then they jerked to a higher energy level, their electrons sending out light that was a little more energetic, or bluer. If that is conclusion is valid, then we can look at the redshift measurements and determine that the Zero Point Energy has changed through time. According to the redshifts we see, that change was quite dramatic at first and then slowed down. Virtual Particles We have learned that the Zero Point Energy is made up of all wavelengths, although the vast majority are the tiny ones. They are all around us going in all directions at once. That is interesting enough, but what they do when they hit each other is quite amazing. Remember Einstein’s equation – E=mc2 ? Every time those waves collide, they form, for the briefest instant, something called a virtual particle pair – one part positive and one part negative. Almost immediately, that pair slams back together and becomes energy again.
Fig. 2: When ocean waves meet, they crest and form whitecaps, which soon disappear. In the same way, when the ZPE energy waves meet, the concentration of energy forms particle pairs (positive and negative), which only exist for the fraction of a second before slamming back together, becoming energy again. As cosmic stretching continued, more energy was invested in space, resulting in more and more virtual particles at any one time. At the very beginning of creation, when that vast potential energy had just started to convert to the kinetic energy of the ZPE, there were not many waves, so there were not many collisions and therefore not many virtual particles. But, like the balloon and rubber band, the conversion at first happened very quickly and so the waves and therefore the resulting numbers of virtual particles at any one time built up quickly. Since universal expansion meant that more energy was being invested in the fabric of space, space itself became ‘thicker’ with virtual particle pairs over time. Today, the estimate is that there are about 1063 virtual particle pairs in existence at any given time in one cubic meter of space. That is a 1 with 63 zeros after it. This vast number of positive and negative pairs in existence at any one time is why both the electric and magnetic qualities of space are related to the strength of the ZPE – the strength of Planck’s ‘h’ [9]. When the Conversion Stopped There came a time when the conversion of potential to kinetic energy was finished. The universe had finished expanding. But there came a time when the basic amount of virtual particles was no longer increasing by vast amounts. Was the universe, from that time on, static? No. Evidence and mathematics indicate there has been an oscillation – think of the way a water balloon behaves when it gets wobbled [10], [11]. This oscillation is going to be very important in a moment. The Speed of Light The tiniest bit of light energy is called a photon. A photon is produced when an electron, forced out of its orbit by something, snaps back. The energy it releases in that snapping is a photon of light. Light energy can be, and is, absorbed by different things: your shirt, the wall, your skin, etc. Virtual particles can also absorb a photon of light. But the virtual particle pair will clap back together almost instantaneously, releasing that captured photon to continue its journey. “Almost instantaneous” is, however, a tiny amount of time. If the photon only has to navigate its way through a hundred virtual particle pairs from the sun to the earth, that’s no big deal and light would get here in a second or so. But each photon of light must get through trillions and trillions of virtual particles on its way from the sun to us, and so what should only take a second or two now takes over eight minutes. This process was analyzed in 2013 by Marcel Urban and his team of astrophysicists at the University of Paris [12]. They reproduced the current speed of light from the interaction times of light photons with virtual particles in the vacuum. They write specifically:
For several hundred years, light speed was being measured by physicists in different countries using different methods. As time went on, the measurements indicated that the speed of light seemed to be slightly, but steadily, slowing. This became a major point of discussion in science journals [13], [14].
Then, in 1941, Raymond Birge of the University of California, Berkeley, declared the speed of light to be a constant through time, ignoring all the data [15]. As recently as a few years ago, it was again declared a constant. But the way they measured it now was through other atomic processes, unlike the physical processes of the past. The problem with that is that the ZPE affects ALL atomic processes, so measuring one by another is a bit like measuring one piece of elastic by another as you stretch both – the change in one piece cannot be measured by the change in the other piece. The measured slowing of light speed abruptly reversed in 1970, when it appeared to be increasing slightly. It was this that indicated an oscillation was occurring. The important thing was that the speed of light was NOT a constant, regardless of what we had all been taught. Another thing was that its connection to the ZPE was becoming apparent. Thus, when the ZPE was quite low, at the beginning, light speed would have been incredibly fast compared to now. Mathematically, the light from the center of our galaxy could reach earth in less than five minutes. Today, that same trip takes over 26,000 years. That is courtesy of the incredible number of virtual particles that light must navigate. Measuring Time The way we measure time in our daily lives is due to gravity – the earth circling the sun once is a year; the earth turning on its axis once is a day. The very word ‘month’ is taken from ‘moon,’ and may be an indication that one orbit of the moon around the earth was a month. And for thousands of years, that way of determining time was quite sufficient for all our needs. But in 1955, with the creation of the first cesium-beam atomic clock, atomic time became measurable. That was time as determined by atomic processes, such as electron orbits. The use of atomic time became an official global standard in 1967. The assumption was that atomic time would calibrate up to orbital time and that the run rate of the two clocks would match. Gravitational motions can be accurately predicted by both Newton’s and Keplar’s laws. It can be shown that, with any changes in the ZPE strength, the gravitational clock will remain unchanged, as all ZPE-dependent quantities in the equations cancel out, leaving just the bare gravitational interaction. So gravity is not affected by changes in the Zero Point Energy. Atomic processes are. The two clocks would be running at exactly the same rate since the beginning if, and only if, there had been no changes affecting atomic clocks – no changes in the Zero Point Energy. So has it been checked with actual data? Yes, it has. The lunar and planetary orbital periods, which are part of the gravitational clock, have been compared with atomic clocks from 1955-1981 by Van Flandern and others, using a variety of methods, including radar and laser ranging. Assessing the evidence in 1984, Van Flandern wrote: “the number of atomic seconds in an orbital interval is becoming fewer. Presumably, if the result has any generality to it, this means that atomic phenomena are slowing down with respect to orbital phenomena….” [16]. Other observatories have continued to monitor this trend. One analysis stated [17]: “Recently, several independent investigators have reported discrepancies between the optical observations [which constitute the gravitational clock] and the planetary ephemerides [which are based on atomic time].
This graph plots the data from the planet Mercury. The behavior of the atomic timing of events for that planet is on the vertical axis. The stable gravitational (orbital) time from optical observations of the same actual planetary events, is recorded horizontally. Similar plots can be made for other solar system objects. These data show the atomic clock is slowing against the orbital (gravitational) standard. Gravity vs. Electromagnetism Gravity, actually, is a weak force. You defy it every time to lift up your foot to walk, or lift a pen to write, or pick up anything. But gravity is what we know. We know our solar system is run gravitationally, with little Mercury spinning around the sun in 88 days, but Neptune, the outermost planet, requiring over 160 ‘earth’ years for one orbit around the sun. Nevertheless, the sun’s gravity is strong enough to hold us all in orbit. Because of this, scientists have long considered gravity to be the major force active in the universe. And this has raised a couple of giant problems. First, using gravity, galaxy formation takes too long. For example, a galaxy like our own Milky Way system is expected to take something in excess of one billion years to form by gravitational means. Yet the images obtained from the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) reveal fully formed galaxies like ours in less than a quarter of that one billion years from the moment of the inception of the cosmos, which is usually called the ‘Big Bang’. This has caused some deep concern in astronomical circles. The second problem has to do with galaxy rotation rates. The outer arms of the galaxies SHOULD be rotating much more slowly than the inner arms around the cores, just like Neptune takes so long to orbit the sun compare to Mercury which is so close to the sun. But what astronomers were seeing was the outer arms rotating just as fast as the inner arms. This is why they presumed so much dark matter must exist – to exert the gravitational pull that would keep the speed so high. There is something much stronger than gravity out there. It is the ZPE’s electromagnetism. In space, electromagnetism is about 1039 times stronger than gravity. Is there evidence of that force out there? Yes, there is. We are all aware of the three states of matter: solid, liquid and gas. The addition of heat energy or the removal of it is what changes a substance to go from one state to another. But when you super-heat or electrically charge a gas, the very atoms themselves begin losing their electrons and/or the nuclei become dissociated. These ionized atoms then form the fourth state of matter – a plasma. When we look out in space, 99% of what we see is plasma. It forms both sheets and filaments, as well and simply being loose, wandering bits. Space itself is not hot. It is not heat which produces or maintains the plasma. It is the moving electrical charges of the electrons within them – electrical currents. We see plasma in our daily lives: lightning, neon signs, the beautiful northern and southern lights (auroras). We can play with plasma filaments in plasma balls. And we can work with plasma filaments in the lab. Plasma filaments will interact with one another. Two of them moving in the same direction will attract each other and start spinning around each other. It was as early as 1987 that Dr. Anthony Peratt was experimenting with interacting plasma filaments at Los Alamos National Labs [18]. He found that when two or more plasma filaments interacted, miniature galaxies formed at the point of interaction in less than a second. The whole range of galaxies seen in outer space could be reproduced using two to 12 such filaments. The whole process was filmed, timed, recorded and reported – they are repeatable scientific experiments. The following figure shows one such interaction and comparison with the galaxy M 81.
Looking down at two interacting plasma filaments in the Los Alamos National Laboratory, a full miniature spiral galaxy formed in less than a second. The right hand picture is galaxy M81, shown for comparison. Two points emerge from these experiments. The first is that the outer parts of the galaxies formed by plasma interaction under electromagnetism rotate at the same rate as the inner parts by the nucleus. The fact that galaxies do not behave as expected with gravity either points to the fact they were formed by plasma processes under electromagnetism, or there is a lot of matter missing for gravity to be driving the rotation rate. After over 50 years of searching, the ‘missing matter’ or ‘dark matter’ has never been found. The second is that the timing of galaxy formation in the lab can be upscaled to the examples we see in space. When this is done, it turns out that the formation of galaxies by plasma processes will only take 30 to 50 million years. This is more than enough time to overcome astronomers’ difficulties. These times are for plasma interactions given the present strength of the ZPE. Any change in ZPE strength would also affect the rate of galaxy formation. The Zero Point Energy acts as an impeding force in atomic processes. The lower the ZPE, the faster the processes. This would include everything from radioactive decay to galaxy formation. In the early universe, as expansion was beginning, electric currents were stronger, voltages were higher, capacitances were lower, ion drift velocities in plasma filaments were faster, as were all plasma interaction times (when compared to the present). The electric and magnetic properties of free space have both increased in proportion to the ZPE strength. Effects in Biology Creatures around the world transmit information via nerve impulses to and from the brain. The nerve cells which do this are called ‘axons.’ Nerve pulses involve the movement of charged particles or ions under the action of potential difference, or voltage. This is the classical definition of an electric current. Biologists Malmivuo and Plonsey have established that the three major factors defining speed of the electric current through the axon are the capacitance and diameter of the axon, as well as the initiating voltage [19]. The analysis above suggests that the lower ZPE strength in the early universe would result in intrinsically faster currents. This suggests that faster nerve transmission could possibly support larger bodily sizes across a whole spectrum of creatures on the early earth. All vertebrates (animals with a backbone) today have nerves that have a special insulating factor called myelin. Myelin is a type of fatty tissue that surrounds the “arm” of the nerve cell.
In the above diagram, the electrical signals are collected by the body of the cell on the left, passed through the ‘arm’ and exit on the right, to be collected by the next nerve cell. The myelin prevents those electrical signals from spreading out all over. It keeps them directional. This allows nerve signals – electrical impulses – to travel very quickly to and from the brain. Animals without backbones – invertebrates – in our world today, do not have myelin sheaths. As a result, their nerve impulses can easily scatter through their whole bodies. By necessity, this means they must stay relatively small. Invertebrates make up about 95% of all creatures on our planet today. And yet, in the geologic record, we see something amazing: gigantic invertebrates. In Figure 5 there are, among other examples, three impressive examples of giant fossil invertebrates: a dragonfly with a wingspan of almost 3 feet, a millipede 8 feet long, and a ‘sea-scorpion’ up to 8.5 feet in size.
Currently, science seems to have no effective answer to this dilemma [20]. Nevertheless, if a lower ZPE was the normal condition in the early history of our planet, this might present an answer. A low ZPE strength would mean that the transmission velocity of all electric currents would be significantly higher. As expansion went on and the ZPE continued to build, the transmission velocity of electric currents and nerve signals would drop. This means that only successively smaller varieties of those invertebrates would survive. These fossils may thus be evidence that the ZPE has been building since earlier times in cosmic history. Some of those invertebrates were not the only things that were large – what about the dinosaurs? All the fossils we have found tell us they had backbones. So we presume they, also, had myelinated nerve cells. Life would have been impossible for them if they did not have the myelin. Dr. David Colman, Director of Montreal Neurological Institute and Hospital explains why: "Imagine a giant sauropod (a dinosaur like Apatosaurus) whose nerves were [like an invertebrate]. Bitten in the tail by a predator, it would take a full 40 seconds for action potentials [nerve impulses] to ascend the length of the tail, body and neck to reach the brain, and another 40 seconds for the signal to return to the tail muscles. Is there any doubt that this reaction time would be incompatible with a successful defensive or escape response?" [21]. Dinosaurs and insects were not the only things that used to be so large. Fossils of giant plants have also been found. This can be tied to two possible causes. The first is carbon dioxide. In photosynthesis, plants absorb light from the sun and carbon dioxide from the air. This is combined with water uptake from the roots and various other chemicals in a process which separates the carbon from the oxygen. Most of the oxygen is then given off as a waste material (which we depend on in our lives), and the carbon is combined with the water to make a carbohydrate – the food we eat. The amount of carbon dioxide in the air has everything to do with plant growth and health. When we look at materials such as amber from long ago, we can see the air trapped in them. The carbon dioxide levels then were over seven times what we have in our air now.
But there was something else. Analyzing the effects of a lower ZPE strength, with the resulting faster lightspeed, it seems possible to at least partially account for the gigantism of Paleozoic flora, as well as their abundance. Plants, algae, bacteria and phytoplankton either grow or proliferate by various forms of photosynthesis. When the behavior of light waves is considered in the context of a much lower ZPE in the early universe, it can be demonstrated that, although there were an increased number of photons being released since atomic processes were faster, the actual energy of any given photon was lower. A basic formula applies in such cases. It states that, for any given wave, the square of the wave amplitude (or height) multiplied by the wave velocity is a constant [22]. It can thus be shown that the intensity of the radiation in the early cosmos was constant even though there were more photons or waves arriving per unit time. This has been examined in detail in conference presentations [23]. Photosynthesis occurs when the energy in photons of light is converted to chemical energy by the organism. The photons are collected by the plant’s “antenna complex.” An incoming photon will elevate an electron from an orbit in an antenna complex molecule to an excited position so that this electron now carries the photon energy. A series of electron transfers then takes place down a potential energy chain to one of the central reaction centers. This stream, or cascade, of electrons is again the definition of an electric current. More incoming photons mean more released electrons which then cascade down to the reaction centers in a stronger and faster current. The energy from the electron current is then used to make ATP and NADPH. These molecules supply energy for metabolic processes that cause plant growth. Since their production originates from electromagnetic interactions, they are both ZPE dependent. The outcome is that, with a lower ZPE in the earlier days, photosynthesis would have been faster as currents were faster, and potentials intrinsically greater. This meant that, combined with a higher carbon dioxide content in the air, much more energy was available for growth compared to today’s varieties [20]. Redder Light & Life in the Early Cosmos: There is one other form of gigantism to be considered: stromatolites. These strange formations, formed by cyanobacteria, are found in the fossil record before the cryogenic strata (which are lower than the Cambrian). The ancient ones were up to eight feet across. Today they only grow to be anywhere from a few centimeters up to three feet in diameter. The above three pictures are all from Australia. On the left is a stromatolite fossil reef. In the middle is the oldest known stromatolite fossil over four feet in diameter), and the right hand picture is of stromatolites today in Shark Bay, western Australia. In 2023 the key to the situation was found. To understand it, we need a quick review of the redshift as discussed above [24]. First, all atomic orbits have remained unchanged. That is important. But as the ZPE increased through time, the orbit energies increased. This meant that the light emitted from the atoms’ electrons became more energetic, or bluer. So even light from our sun was redder in the early days and bluer now [20]. This is a big help with our investigation because cyanobacteria use photosynthesis to produce stromatolites. We look at the massive examples of stromatolites in the fossil record of the Archean and Proterozoic, and then wonder why this activity died quickly in the following era. Today’s examples are diminutive in comparison, as seen in the images above. Experiments established that these same cyanobacteria had not one, but two modes of operation; one in far red light, the other in blue light like today, and they can switch between modes rapidly [25]. In addition, when compared with the blue-light conditions of today, the far-red light adaption has a 30% greater output of oxygen and 40% greater production in other areas when the same cells are fully operational [26]. Early stromatolite fossils indicate the red mode gave the massive reef structures, while the blue light gave the more diminutive forms seen today. The implication is that, in the Archean and Proterozoic eras, the sun was emitting redder light because of the lower ZPE. Then, as cosmic expansion went on, the ZPE strengthened and the sun emitted progressively bluer light. The stromatolite mechanism switched during this process and the massive fossil reef-building ceased. This, then, seems to be evidence of a changing ZPE from some examples in the fossil record. Conclusion: Planck’s first paper in 1901 presented an unknown quantity he called ‘h’ which seemed to solve a lot of problems scientists were having with equations regarding a type of radiation. Planck spent ten years trying to figure out what ‘h’ represented and presented his conclusion in 1911: ‘h’ was a factor representing energy in the universe itself. Testing through the years showed this energy was present even when all physical substances as well as heat energy were taken out of a vacuum. For this reason it was called Zero Point Energy, or ZPE. In the last fifty years, the ZPE has been shown to be the root cause of a number of other things: the red shift of light from distant galaxies, the different rates of orbital and gravitational time, a changing speed of light, galaxy formation, and even gigantism on the early earth. This paper has attempted to present a layman’s summary of a lot of this. Much more can be found in “Cosmology and the Zero Point Energy” which is being re-issued this month, as well as the other referenced papers listed below.
|